Mystery & Glow-in-the-Dark Puzzles | Nightmare Puzzles

Games So Tough They Give You Nightmares

Galison Occult and Curious – 1000 Piece Glow in The Dark Jigsaw Puzzle Featuring an Eerie Collection of Creepy and Spooky Objects

Galison Occult and Curious – 1000 Piece Glow in The Dark Jigsaw Puzzle Featuring an Eerie Collection of Creepy and Spooky Objects

Regular price $45.98 USD

Regular price ~~$45.98 USD~~ Sale price $45.98 USD
Unit price per
Glow In The Dark Poker Cards

Glow In The Dark Poker Cards

Regular price $20.44 USD

Regular price ~~$20.44 USD~~ Sale price $20.44 USD
Unit price per
Murder Mystery Party | Classic Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle Death on The Istanbul Express 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle Orange

Murder Mystery Party | Classic Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle Death on The Istanbul Express 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle Orange

Regular price $53.98 USD

Regular price ~~$53.98 USD~~ Sale price $53.98 USD
Unit price per
Pandasaurus Games The Mind - Family-Friendly Board Games - Game Night - Card Games for Adults Teens & Kids (2-4 Players)

Pandasaurus Games The Mind - Family-Friendly Board Games - Game Night - Card Games for Adults Teens & Kids (2-4 Players)

Regular price $32.99 USD

Regular price ~~$32.99 USD~~ Sale price $32.99 USD
Unit price per

🧩 This Week’s Nightmare Pick

PRFOKEY Impossible Puzzle

A hexagonal labyrinth of despair. Every piece looks like it fits… until it doesn’t.

Difficulty: Impossible

““I almost threw it off the table — but I couldn’t stop.””

Featured puzzle image

loading="lazy" /> 🛒 Shop Now